Sell your Magic cards — one card or a whole collection

Your choice when you accept our offer: PayPal Goods & Services, or Geega Games store credit worth 20% more than the PayPal amount (a $100 PayPal offer becomes $120 in credit). Store credit is saved to a free account and works on any singles in our shop.

We look at what each card is selling for right now, how quickly it sells and what condition it's in, then make one offer on the whole lot. Until we see the cards in person, we go by a starting condition based on each card's age.

Until we see them, each card starts at a condition based on its age: 2005 or earlier at Heavily Played, 2006–2015 at Moderately Played, newer cards at Lightly Played, and brand-new cards at Near Mint. We check every card when it arrives, and your offer goes up or down to match what's really there — we'll tell you which cards changed and why.

Tell us which card and why, and we'll take another look — a clear photo helps. You're never obligated: if we can't agree, you can decline the offer, and if you've already shipped your cards, we send them back (you cover the return shipping).

That's fine — there's no obligation. We send your cards back, and you cover the return shipping.

No. Ship it or meet up with it exactly as it is — in binders, boxes, bags, or a mix of all three. Sorting it yourself doesn't get you a better offer, and for a large collection it usually just delays things.

Not at all. Most people selling a large collection haven't priced it and don't need to. We go through everything and make an offer based on what's actually there.

That's the normal case, not an edge case. Most real collections are a mix — a few cards worth looking at closely and a lot that aren't. Send it all; we sort out what's what.

No. A few good singles or a few thousand cards are both fine. For a handful of cards, our Sell page lets you add each card individually; for binders, boxes or anything unsorted, the quick photo quote on this page is the fastest way in.

Yes. Use our Sell page to search for and add your cards one at a time in a couple of clicks, or send a few photos through the quick photo quote on this page — whichever is easier.

Either works. In the St. Louis area we're glad to meet up in person. For collections, we'll also drive to you anywhere within about a 6-hour drive of St. Louis — Kansas City, Chicago, Indianapolis, Louisville, Nashville, Memphis and everywhere in between. From anywhere else in the US, ship it to us. Tell us your preference in the form.

For a collection, yes — that's the point. For longer trips we'll ask for a few photos and a rough idea of what's there first, so we can plan the day and make sure the trip makes sense for both of us. A handful of singles is usually easier to ship.

Somewhere public that you're comfortable with. Coffee shops, libraries and game stores work well, and many police departments have designated safe-exchange spots. For a very large collection that's hard to move, tell us in the form and we'll work out the easiest option.

No — shipping in works from anywhere in the US. We're based in St. Louis, and for sellers within about a 6-hour drive — including Missouri, Illinois, Kentucky, Indiana, Tennessee, Arkansas, Kansas, Iowa, Oklahoma — meeting in person is an option too.

You have five main options. List them yourself on TCGplayer or eBay (the most money per card, but roughly 13% or more in fees plus all the listing and shipping work). Sell to an online buylist (quick, but you look up and ship every card yourself). Sell to a local game store (fast, but many only buy what they need). Or sell everything at once to a collection buyer like us — one offer for the whole lot, sorted or not, by mail or in person. Our Where to sell Magic cards guide compares them in detail.